The Salem-Keizer School District says there is “unavoidable tension” between academic performance and equity in deciding which elementary schools to close. There is no such tension. There is a deliberate choice to set aside the district’s own mission.
A school exists to educate children. The school board said so and directed the district to prioritize specific academic outcomes, including third-grade reading proficiency. Those goals are the standard the district set for whether it is doing its core job. Yet the criteria used to recommend closing six schools omit academic performance entirely. When parents asked why, they were told that higher results were, in effect, unacceptable because they correlate with wealth. Superintendent Castañeda called this an “unavoidable tension.”
It is not unavoidable. It is a decision to treat the district’s own measure of success as a problem. This cannot be reconciled with the district’s core mission. The board has declared third-grade reading and other academic outcomes central. Excluding them from a decision that will reshape elementary education for years is not a neutral technical choice. It is not merely bias. It is a contradiction. Better learning cannot be both a priority and an equity risk at the same time.
The defense repeatedly offered by the district is that critics want academics to be the only factor. That is a straw man. No one has argued that academic results should be the sole criterion. Enrollment, building condition, capacity, and community factors all matter. The objection is that academic performance has been excluded altogether despite being the outcome the district says it exists to produce. Pointing out that omission is not the same as demanding it dominate every other consideration.
Equity does not require this exclusion. Equity is not achieved by discarding evidence of what works or by treating higher proficiency as something to be neutralized. As parents have said, equity is not lowering high scores to meet lower scores; it is giving every student the opportunity to rise.
The wealth correlation is real in the aggregate. It is not an instruction to ignore results, and it is not destiny. Schools and teachers produce different outcomes under different conditions. Some schools recommended for closure have higher proficiency rates. Declaring those results off-limits does not honor the educators who created them and the students who achieved them. It erases both.
The practical stakes follow directly. Students will move from higher-performing schools to lower-performing ones. Research on school closures shows that such transitions often produce measurable learning loss, particularly when receiving schools have lower proficiency. The district’s plans for continuity of instruction and growth tracking may mitigate some effects after the fact. They do not explain why the results that predict those effects were left out of the criteria.
Board members have already flagged the contradiction. One asked why closure decisions should not align with the academic goals the district has explicitly tied to desired outcomes. Another called the omission contradictory. These are not peripheral complaints. They follow directly from the board’s own statements about what matters.
There is no unavoidable tension between equity and academic outcomes. There is only a choice about whether the purpose of schooling will be allowed to influence a major structural decision. If better learning is treated as unacceptable, the district is not preparing children for future success. It is redefining success so the evidence of it no longer counts. Academic results need not be the only factor. Our community cannot accept that academics be the one factor the district refuses to consider.


